A look at what is currently available on eBay
Is there a store similar to Old Time Pottery in McHenry County, IL?
I am new to the area and we had Old Time Pottery in Florida. It is a large warehouse type retail that had affordable home accessories, fake flowers, kitchen supplies, pottery, art, glassware, outdoor furniture, wicker, etc. Is there anything similar to this near Crystal Lake, IL or Barrington, IL?
Congrats on moving to the Northwest Suburbs.
Drive down to Algonquin. There's a Home Goods store down there that might fill your needs. There's a whole lot of other stores you can get affordable stuff from, so don't feel locked into one just for convenience.
Word of advice (as if you need more): better to decorate little by little than try to establish a theme all at once. My wife and I have taken almost four years to decorate our house, from painting the walls to the last wall hanging, and we're not done yet. We've been patient in finding just the right items that fit into a theme. Besides, our finances didn't take a massive hit all at once. 
Items recently purchased from this site
CATALINA ISLAND ART POTTERY LARGE LOW BLUE BOWL TIERED STAR FLOWER FROG 1927-37 , "HUGE!!" ROSEVILLE BLACKBERRY ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE BLUE PINECONE 910-10 ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE ANTIQUE MINT!!, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE ELEPHANT FOOT BLUE WISTERIA ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE MINT!!, "BEST!!" ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE FERELLA ART POTTERY GARDEN FLOWER LG. VASE # 510-9, "BEST!!" ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE FUTURA MILK CARTON ART POTTERY CUT FLOWERS VASE MINT, XX RARE CIRCA 1915 ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE PURPLE CARNELIAN II ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE FERELLA ART POTTERY DECO FLOWER GARDEN PREMIUM QUALITY VASE , ANTIQUE 12 " WELLER GLENDALE BIRDS IN NEST ART POTTERY WALL POCKET FLOWERS VASE , ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE SUNNY FARM SUNFLOWER ART DECO POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN VASE , ANTIQUE ARTS & CRAFTS EMBOSSED OWENS MATTE GREEN FLOWER GARDEN POTTERY VASE MINT, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE SUNFLOWER ART POTTERY FLOWER BOWL, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE BANEDA ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE DECO, ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE FERELLA ART DECO POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN SCULPTURE HOME VASE , LG. ANTIQUE GARDEN GOURD HAMPSHIRE MATTE GREEN ARTS CRAFTS POTTERY FLOWER VASE , ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE FUTURA ART DECO POTTERY VASE RETRO GARDEN FLOWER STATUE POT , ROSEVILLE NUDE SILHOUETTE ART DECO FLOWER POTTERY VASE, ARTS CRAFTS POTTERY VASE GARDEN FLOWER ART DECO MISSION, "HUGE!!" ANTIQUE WELLER ARTS CRAFTS FROSTED ART POTTERY CUT FLOWERS VASE DECO, ROSEVILLE TALL BANEDA ART POTTERY FLOWER MISSION VASE, Cowan vintage art pottery flower frog figurine - dancing girl with scarf - large, Royal Bonn art pottery vase with hand painted flowers, ROSEVILLE PINECONE ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE PINE CONE , ROSEVILLE MISSION FALLINE FLOWERS ART DECO POTTERY VASE, # 2 ROSEVILLE NUDE SILHOUETTE ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, ROSEVILLE SUNFLOWER ART POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN BOWL VASE, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE TOPEO ART POTTERY DECO FLOWER VASE, ANTIQUE COLBALT 10 " ROSEVILLE PINECONE ART POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN DECO VASE NICE, "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE SUNFLOWER ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, ROSEVILLE SUNFLOWER ART POTTERY GARDEN FLOWER URN VASE , "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE BLACKBERRY ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, Vintage American Art Pottery Signed Weller Coppertone Bowl and Flower Frog, ROSEVILLE MONTACELLO ART POTTERY VASE MONTICELLO FLOWER, "BEST!!" ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE LG. BLUE TOPEO ART POTTERY DECO FLOWER BUTRESS VASE , ANTIQUE DECO ROSEVILLE BROWN PINECONE ART POTTERY LG. FLOWER GARDEN TREE VASE , Vintage Signed Weller American Art Pottery Bowl + Kingfisher Flower Frog , Amphora Art Pottery Roses flowers Vase Bohemian Figurine handle basket, Moorcroft art pottery vase with bright flowers, 1918 ROOKWOOD TURQUOISE VELLUM GLAZE ART POTTERY FLOWER BUD VASE CENTERPIECE, ROSEVILLE BLACKBERRY ART POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN VASE, ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE INDIAN MONTACELLO ART POTTERY FLOWER DECO VASE MONTICELLO , ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE CARNELIAN ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE , ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE CARNELIAN II ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, ROSEVILLE BANEDA ART POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN DECO VASE, 7.5 " SEA WAVES HAMPSHIRE ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE MINT, ROSEVILLE JONQUIL FLOWER ART POTTERY BOWL N' FROG VASE, BLOSSOM FLITE HULL ART POTTERY MASSIVE FRUIT CONSOLE FLOWER BOWL VASE, LG. WELLER BLUE CORNISH ART POTTERY FLOWER DECO VASE , ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE ART POTTERY GREEN HANDLED FLOWER VASE, Cowan vintage art pottery flower frog figurine - dancing girl with scarf - white, Bjorn Wiinblad Art Pottery Head Vase Flower Pot 1972, WELLER Art Pottery Woodcraft FOXES Vase, 3 Cubs -Flower Frog-Beautiful, Large French Slip Majolica Jardiniere Art Pottery Vase with Poppy Flower 18" , ROSEVILLE WISTERIA FLOWERS MISSION ART POTTERY VASE , ANTIQUE WELLER AMERICAN ART POTTERY APPLE TREE DOUBLE BUD FLOWER GARDEN VASE , WELLER ART POTTERY TREE VASE FLOWERS FLEMISH GARDEN ART, ANTIQUE WELLER CORNISH ART POTTERY MISSION FLOWER VASE, ROSEVILLE GREEN LUFFA ART POTTERY FLOWER MISSION VASE, "BEST!!" ANTIQUE WELLER APPLE TREE ART POTTERY CUT FLOWERS GARDEN CHALICE VASE, ANTIQUE WELLER ART POTTERY DOUBLE APPLE ORCHARD TREE FLOWER BUD STICK VASE MINT , "BEST!!" ROSEVILLE BLUE MOSS ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE, LG. ANTIQUE RETRO MODERN ART DECO WELLER POTTERY PASTEL FLOWER VASE MISSION , Vintage Studio ART Pottery FLOWER FROG BAbs WELLSTEED #, Gouda art pottery vase with bright flowers design, Antique Art Pottery Red PALLISY Majolica Flower Vase, ELEGANT DEEP BLUE CLEMATIS MOORCROFT FLOWER VASE - ANTIQUE ART POTTERY ENGLAND, LARGE Oriental "Blue Bird & Flowers" Art Pottery Vase, Moorcroft art pottery vase with flowers - marked, Roseville art pottery jardiniere - Rozanne with flowers, WELLER POTTERY, CORNISH BLUE FLOWER VASE, ARTS & CRAFTS~~, Antique Wardle Art Pottery Teck Ware Green Vase Orange Flowers England , ROSEVILLE FUCHSIA ART POTTERY FLOWER GARDEN VASE #898-8, ANTIQUE WELLER ART DECO POTTERY LARGE LADY BUST MISSION FLOWER SCULPTURE VASE, ANTIQUE WELLER ART POTTERY TALL APPLE ORCHARD TREE FLOWER BUD STICK VASE MINT , # 2 ANTIQUE WELLER ART POTTERY APPLE ORCHARD TREE FLOWER BUD STICK VASE MINT , ANTIQUE ART POTTERY FLOWER VASE NIPPON DECO PAINTING, ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE POTTERY IRIS FLOWER ART DECO VASE , Pansies Flowers Large 20" Platter 17" Handpainted Pottery Portuguese Floral Art, Glorious SIGNED AB Art Pottery BOWL Joyous COLORS Very PRETTY Flower SHAPE Old, Pottery Barn Botanical Flower Wood Picture Wall Art , Art Deco Leaping Stag Weller Pottery Flower Frog!, Art Pottery Bowl Vase Vintage 4 Handles Flowers Signed, Vintage Putti/Cherub Art Pottery Figure& Barbotine Flowers Signed Roban , FLOWER GARDEN PORCELAIN POTTERY ART LAMP NIPPON DECO, Roseville Art Pottery Freesia Flower Pot w Saucer Brown, Vintage Modern Arabia Finland Art Pottery Flower Lamp 18" HLA/SL, 1920s Weller Antique American Art Pottery - APPLE TREE FLOWER GARDEN VASE, ANTIQUE 1937 WELLER ART POTTERY GREEN SCENIC FLOWER VASE ~ FLORAL ART DECO RARE , Arts & Crafts ROOKWOOD POTTERY Vase Band of Flowers, Unique Art Pottery Multipurpose Candleholder or Flower Design Centerpiece, "BEST!" #1 ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE BLUE APPLE BLOSSOM ART POTTERY TREE BUD FLOWER VASE, "BEST!" #2 ANTIQUE ROSEVILLE BLUE APPLE BLOSSOM ART POTTERY TREE BUD FLOWER VASE, Weller Art Nouveau Pottery Frog in Water Lily Flower, Pansies Flowers Large 17" Platter Handpainted Pottery Portugal Botanical Art, Marvelous Arts & Craft Flower Pottery Vase, WHITE SKYSCRAPER FLOWERS ELECTRIC COBALT BLUE SLIP GLAZE HAYDEN ART POTTERY VASE, SET of 3 JAPANESE Art Pottery VASE 1960s Collection MASHIKO has FLOWER SIGNATURE, Yellow Majolica Art Pottery Plate w/ White Flowers, EARLY ROSEVILLE PLANTER VASE LOW BOWL DOGWOOD FLOWER ART POTTERY ,
